Now follow us on Instagram All Good Record Shops on Instagram

Why Musicians are Leaving Streaming Services: A Growing Trend

Why Musicians are Leaving Streaming Services: A Growing Trend

Platforms like Spotify and Apple Music have transformed the way we listen to music. However, not every artist is on board with these changes. Recently, several high-profile musicians have removed their work from streaming services, citing issues such as unfair royalties and ethical concerns. These artists include Taylor Swift, Neil Young and Joni Mitchell – although some objections may be related to Spotify continuing to allow Joe Rogan’s podcast to promote anti vax propaganda.

A leading reason for artists leaving streaming services is the minimal compensation per stream. While streaming services provide musicians with access to millions of listeners, the revenue generated from each play is often negligible. Independent and mid-level artists, in particular, struggle to earn a sustainable income.

Musicians typically earn only $0.003 to $0.005 per stream on Spotify.

This rate can vary across different platforms and as a guide, here’s a rough approximate of what the main streaming services pay per stream:

  • Spotify: Approximately $0.003 to $0.005 per stream.
  • Apple Music: Around $0.007 to $0.01 per stream.
  • Amazon Music: Between $0.004 and $0.005 per stream.
  • Tidal: Generally higher, about $0.012 to $0.015 per stream.
  • YouTube Music: Roughly $0.00069 per stream.
  • Deezer: $0.0064 per stream.
  • Pandora – $0.00133 per stream on Pandora Premium.
  • Qobuz: Around $0.043 per stream.
  • SoundCloud doesn’t reveal how much it pays per stream, but musicians on SoundCloud make money from different sources, like revenue from ads and getting support directly from fans who subscribe to SoundCloud Go+.

Source: How much do streaming services pay musicians?

Convenience vs. Supporting Artists

Fans also face a dilemma as more artists leave major streaming services. On one hand, streaming platforms offer unparalleled convenience by granting users access to vast music libraries. On the other hand, the growing awareness of how little artists earn from these services has prompted some listeners to reconsider their choices.

More fans are now opting to support musicians directly by purchasing physical albums or using platforms like Bandcamp.

British Folk rock super group The Magpie Arc recently described the predicament in fantastic detail:

The Importance Of Downloads!

Welcome to all our new followers and mailing list subscribers who have joined us in the last few weeks through our free/pay what you want Anthology download album. Hope you’re enjoying our music and hopefully we’ll see you at a gig sometime too.

A lot of people have asked why we have made our collection available for free/pay what you want so….

As everyone knows the folk world is a wonderful community of people committed to music and we are constantly amazed by the number of emails we get or comments on social media we see about how much they love to support artists by actually buying their music on CD’s and vinyl.

However one area that we find many people think is redundant now are downloads.

Artists often hear that fans who only have physical copies of their music and no means to get it onto their mobile devices feel that the only way to listen to it on the move is to stream it via Spotify/Apple etc. and also fans who no longer have CD players or record decks feel that they have no other listening choice at all.

Well the purpose of this post is to say that this isn’t the case and that downloads still have a very important part to play for music lovers who want to support their favourite artists.

Firstly, a wee calculation of what a £10 download album means to artists financially compared to streaming…..

* 291 listens to a ten song album from start to finish on Spotify using their standard streaming royalty rate will earn an artist £10.

* If you listen to the whole album once a day starting on the 1st of January then it would take until the 17th of October for the artist to earn that £10.

* If you listen to the album once a week starting on the 1st of January 2025 then it would take until the 1st of June 2030 for the artist to earn that £10.

* If you buy a download then they get the £10 right now.

Secondly, and this is the one that not everyone knows about, but once you have music downloaded onto one of your devices you can integrate it into all your Spotify/Apple etc. playlists and can listen to it as you normally do on those platforms. Just search how to integrate downloads into Spotify/Apple etc. online and you’ll find out.

And finally for those of you new to downloads the game-changing resource for all artists who use it is the wonderful site Bandcamp.

If you’re a music lover and you’re not aware of it then check it out as it’s a treasure trove of downloadable music from thousands of established and new artists many of whom will offer content exclusive to the site.

Bandcamp has it’s own excellent free app player for phones/iPads where if you don’t want to integrate your music to streaming playlists or you just plain hate Spotify etc. then you can organise and listen to all your downloads in your car or wherever you go via that.

Bandcamp also offer playback quality far above Spotify and Apple so you’re also getting a much better listening experience.

So there you go, there’s the importance of downloads.

Image by Martine from Pixabay