A recent article by Guardian journalist and author Tom Lamont bemoans the fact he got rid of all his CDs when music streaming took hold of the music industry. In an article entitled “CDs sales are growing. How I wish I hadn’t given my beloved collection away”, he discusses his journey from CD to Napster, MP3s, streaming and back again.
The great shedding of CDs began, at least for me, around the turn of the millennium, when the world went online. I remember first seeing the music-sharing software Napster in action in early 2000.
He started by ripping his collection (remember that) to a hard drive and sending them to MP3 players. He describes himself a piler rather than an archivist of CDs which meant the automated organisation of folders on hard disc enabled music to be found more easily.
The first four albums by Belle and Sebastian had been in heavy rotation for me for years, always in and out of the stereo. Once I’d digitised these albums (in the 2000s, the work of minutes), I hardly touched them again.
Even early devices MP3 devices like the iPod shuffle which were no bigger than a chewing gum packet could hold around 20 albums. With a large enough hard disk and rotation of your albums, the technology could deliver music on the move which rendered the CD a bulky old style music format that was inconvenient and space hungry. If you were willing to accept the reduced audio quality then CD was becoming a burden.
What really was a game changer for Tom was the emergence of Spotify and their competitors.
Even the invisible MP3s on my computer’s hard drive had started to feel fiddly and archaic, an unnecessary burden: so, of course, the last of the CDs had to go. I made the argument to my wife that we should do a clean sweep. I took all the discs we had to an Oxfam on Kentish Town Road. I remember handing the bag over dubiously, with no faith in the resale value of the contents. What a cool thing, I told myself, as I walked away unencumbered, to own no albums… yet somehow to own every album. What freedom! What choice!
While Tom recognises the benefits of streaming in music discovery, he does express some regrets at no longer having his CDs or even a CD player at home.
…there’s an absence now, some loss of connection with the initial creators of these pieces of art, some loss of awareness, too, about the spots they occupy in time and space. Perhaps I’ll stop in a charity shop the next time I pass one: buy a few CDs. Perhaps I’ll go down to the Oxfam on Kentish Town Road and see if I can buy back one or two of my CDs.
Here are some statistics on the rise of CDs:
Some statistics on the rise of CDs
Sales of CDs rose 2% in 2023, the first revenue rise in two decades. In the first half of 2024, £57.9m-worth of CDs were sold – an uptick of 3.2% on the previous year.
• A study by packaging firm Key Production found that gen Z is listening to more vinyl, CDs and cassettes than any other age group.
• Taylor Swift’s recent album, The Tortured Poets Department, has appeared in nine different CD variants to date (and 19 different physical versions in total). Last week, Universal Music Group announced that physical sales revenues increased by 14.4% during 2024’s second quarter, helped by spectacular CD, vinyl and cassette sales for Swift’s new album.
• Ariana Grande’s 2024 album, Eternal Sunshine, came in five CD variants, while Olivia Rodrigo released two CD versions of her 2023 album, Guts.
• Now That’s What I Call Music is the juggernaut that keeps on giving: the series’s albums accounted for six of last year’s 40 bestselling CDs.
The Taylor Swift effect
The Taylor Swift effect is interesting. Here is an artist with a very specific demographic of fans not normally associated with collecting music, releasing physical product on multiple formats. While streaming is good for new music discovery and convenience, once discovered a true music will want something physical from that artist and CD is the obvious choice.
Tom Lamont’s debut novel, Going Home, is out now. To support the Guardian and Observer order your copy at guardianbookshop.com. Delivery charges may apply.
Further reading
CDs sales are growing. How I wish I hadn’t given my beloved collection away
CD sales increase for the first time in 20 years
Photo by cottonbro studio: https://www.pexels.com/photo/person-wearing-a-checkered-shirt-in-the-record-store-6865916/
